Most people who walk through a cafe door for the first time found it on Google Maps. They searched "cafe near me" or "brunch Ponsonby" and your listing showed up. So far, so good. But when they tapped your listing and went looking for more information, what did they find?
If you don't have a website, they found nothing. Or they found your Instagram, scrolled back six weeks to find your hours, and couldn't tell if you were still open. Some of them went to the next listing.
A website doesn't replace Google Maps or Instagram. It backs them up. It's the place where someone can confirm your hours, check your menu, and decide whether to make the trip.
What Google Maps alone won't tell customers
Google Business Profile is good for basics: address, phone, opening hours, a handful of photos. It doesn't tell someone whether you do eggs benny on a weekday, whether you're dog friendly, or whether there's seating for a group of eight. Those are the questions people ask before choosing a cafe, especially for a first visit.
Your website answers those questions without anyone having to call you. That matters. Most people under 40 won't call a cafe to ask a simple question. They'll check your site, and if your site doesn't exist, they'll move on.
What a cafe website actually needs
You don't need a booking system, a loyalty programme sign-up, or a newsletter subscription form. A cafe website needs to do four things:
- Show your menu (what you serve, and roughly what it costs)
- Show your hours and location (with a map embed)
- Show a few photos of the space and the food
- Make it easy to find your phone number
That's it. Keep it short. A single-page site that loads fast beats a five-page site that takes four seconds to open on a phone.
Your menu: PDF or HTML
Either works. A PDF menu is easy to upload and update. HTML menus look cleaner on mobile but take longer to maintain. If you change your menu seasonally or weekly, a PDF is fine. Just make sure the file is current. Nothing loses a customer faster than turning up for a dish that got dropped three months ago.
If you're a brunch-focused cafe, list your most popular dishes on the homepage itself. Flat whites, eggs benny, avocado toast, cabinet food. People scan for familiar items. Give them something to land on.
Photos: the real selling point
One good photo of your cabinet food at 9am is worth more than five paragraphs about your "welcoming atmosphere." NZ cafe culture is specific. People come for the flat white, the cabinet selection, the vibe. Show all three.
You don't need a photographer. A phone with good light is enough. Shoot in the morning when natural light is best. Get the coffee, the cabinet, and the room. Three to six photos on your homepage is plenty.
Online ordering: even a simple option helps
Full online ordering systems like Mr Yum or HungryHungry work well but cost money and take time to set up. If that's not right for you yet, a simple contact form or a click-to-call phone number for phone orders is enough to start.
The goal is to make ordering possible without someone having to come in first. Even a "call to order" prompt on your site beats no ordering option at all. As your cafe grows, you can integrate a proper system.
Why Instagram alone isn't enough
Instagram is where people discover you. It's not where they confirm the details before visiting. The algorithm decides who sees your posts. Your follower count can drop. Meta can change the rules. You don't own any of it.
Your website is yours. It shows up on Google whether you posted last week or last month. The hours are where you put them. The menu is what you wrote. No algorithm involved.
Google also sends more first-time customers than Instagram does, for most cafes. Someone searching "coffee Grey Lynn" is actively looking for somewhere to go right now. An Instagram follower is browsing. The searcher has higher intent. Your website captures that traffic. Your Instagram account doesn't.
What to put on your homepage
Think about what someone wants to know in the first ten seconds. For a cafe, it's: what kind of place is this, where is it, and when is it open. Answer those three things above the fold. Everything else (full menu, story, events) can go below.
NZ cafe culture has its own flavour. If you're known for your flat whites, say so. If you're a brunch spot, lead with that. If you stock a particular roaster's beans, mention it. Specific details build trust faster than generic phrases about "great coffee and good vibes."
How your website and Google listing work together
A Google Business Profile with a linked website ranks better than one without. Google uses your website to verify the information in your listing. If your website says you're open until 3pm on Saturdays and your Google listing says 4pm, Google notices. Keeping both consistent keeps your ranking stable.
Your website also gives customers somewhere to leave a Google review. Add a link to your review page on your site or in your email footer. Reviews are the number one factor in whether a new customer chooses your cafe over the one down the road.
If you want to go deeper on how local search works, read our local SEO guide for NZ small businesses and our guide to setting up Google Business Profile.
What it costs to get a cafe website
Web designers in Auckland and Wellington quote $3,000 to $8,000 for a cafe site. That's before any ongoing maintenance fees. For a small cafe with tight margins, that's a lot of flat whites.
At SiteSorted, a cafe website starts from $299. One payment, no monthly fees, hosting included. You answer a few questions about your cafe and your site gets built with your menu, hours, photos, and contact details. If one new table of four finds you through Google because of your site, it's paid for itself.
Get your cafe online
The setup takes about five minutes. You answer questions about your cafe, and we build you a site that's ready to go live.
Build your free preview now and see what it looks like before you pay anything.
← Back to Blog